Pat Landers’ investment club is evaluating FDS and Pat says his SSG looks like a “strong Buy.” Here’s a comparison of Pat’s SSG and mine along with the analysis by Take Stock On-Line:
|
FACTSET RESEARCH (FDS)
|
Pat
|
Take Stock
|
Armin
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sales Growth
|
14.00%
|
18.50%
|
16.00%
|
|
EPS Growth
|
13.40%
|
18.50%
|
16.00%
|
|
High PE
|
26.0
|
29.9
|
23.0
|
|
High Price
|
$109.20
|
$149.33
|
$108.10
|
|
...Value Line Estimated High Price = $70-105 as of 3-7-08…
|
|
Low PE
|
18.0
|
16.4
|
15.0
|
|
Low Price
|
$40.32
|
$36.57
|
$33.60
|
|
Up/Down Ratio
|
4.7
|
6.3 (imputed)
|
3.0
|
|
Total Return
|
16.9%
|
24.1%
|
16.4%
|
|
Price
|
$52.00
|
$52.00
|
$51.80
|
|
Buy Under
|
$57.54
|
$64.76
|
$52.23
|
|
SSG Date
|
|
3-8-08
|
3-7-08
|
|
SSG Data
|
|
Hemscott
|
S&P
|
COMMENTS:
- The analysts are estimating long-term EPS growth at around 18% with Value Line low at 16.5% and Reuters as well as First Call high at 18.33%. Zacks is 17.00% and S&P and FactSet CallStreet are 18.0%. Reuters less one Standard Deviation, what I use most often (but not here), is 17.1%;
- Pat estimated EPS growth of 13.40% which is a lot less than the analysts, but both our SSGs are very close in terms of results: our Forecast High Price and Total Return are almost identical;
- Take Stock is the surprising exception and is way more optimistic than Pat or myself: its Forecast High Price is some $40 per share more than ours and a whopping $44 or 42% per share more than Value Line;
- VL updated its FDS report on 3-7-08 and: (1) lowered its estimated PE in the next 3-5 years from 22.0 to 20.5; (2) lowered its estimated EPS growth rate from 17.5% to 16.5%; and (3) raised its estimated High Price from $65-100 to $70-105. And, FDS’s price continued to fall some $5.65 per share from the prior VL report three months ago;
- FDS seems like an excellent company and I am most impressed with its 95+% customer retention rate; the big uncertainty is the market;
- There are lots of good-looking companies, with good-looking SSGs, that have been hammered down in price (INFY, SBUX, MDT, COH, FIC, and JKHY for example): I’d seek to choose those that have the best chance of making the best recovery for the long-term.
QUESTIONS:
- What is it about Take Stock On-Line’s programming that makes it so optimistic about FDS, even more optimistic in its EPS estimate than any of the six analysts I checked, even though it is designed to produce a conservative result?
Armin
|