Subject: which accounting program to use?
Prev Topic Next Topic
Note: You must be a StockCentral subscriber and logged in to post messages.
Author Messages

Ronald Park


11/13/2007 6:40 PM  

Our investment club has been using NAIC Online Club Accounting, but is Bivio better (or at least equivalent) ?

If so, it would make cents to make the switch.


Gene Rooks
Gotha, FL (W. of Orlando)


11/13/2007 6:55 PM  
Ronald, IClub, who set up the StockCentral website you used for this question, also produce the Club Accounting Online which you are using under myiclub.com.   bivio is a similar club accounting product produced by another business.  BI/NAIC doesn't make software themselves, or have an onsite accounting program.  Below are my thoughts on the subject.   Financially, bivio is $99 a year including Tax Printer.   CAO from IClub is $59.99 for StockCentral members, and if five club members are paid StockCentral members, the Tax Printer is free.
 

Five reasons why I believe you will be a better treasurer for using Club Accounting Online, at myiclub.com, rather than using bivio club accounting online with AccountSynch:

 

1.     bivio does not utilize a saved monthly valuation. Instead, member entries default to the value on the transaction date unless the treasurer keeps alert that an official valuation date also needs to be entered on each member transaction.  Failing to use the correct valuation date results in incorrect unit values being credited, and incorrect withdrawals being computed.

 

2.      Over-reliance on AccountSynch entries in bivio leads to unspotted and uncorrected errors or omissions in your accounting data.  An inexperienced treasurer can be unaware of this happening, whereas making all your entries yourself challenges you to understand the principles behind what you are doing.  It also makes for a less cluttered looking journal, and eliminates incomprehensible ‘fees’ on reinvested dividends sometimes seen in bivio.

 

3.      CAO reports from myiclub.com are more concise, printer-friendly, understandable and useful than the bivio reports, in my opinion.

 

4.        While both programs offer privacy, all member access, file storage, and email communication, CAO also offers a Watch List, and instant connection to research links through StockCentral, even if you are not a member of StockCentral.  This includes quick access to ex-dividend dates.

 

5.      A new treasurer will reach a level of competence much quicker in CAO, due to personally being in charge of all the entries that go into the accounting data, without having to go behind automated entries to make corrections, additions, or appropriate member or expense allocations.

 

Gene Rooks,

Southern Women Investing Money

Space Coast Chapter


Gene Rooks, Director
Space Coast Chapter
Accounting Instructor

Ronald Park


11/13/2007 7:19 PM  
Thank you for detailed and well-documented advice. I had been leaning toward bivio, but now am leaning back toward CAO. I believe what I shall do is use the free trial period and run bivio simultaneously with CAO to give a fair comparison. I appreciate the list of hazards to watch out for.
Note: You must be a StockCentral subscriber and logged in to post messages.
Forums > Investing > The Clubhouse > which accounting program to use?



ActiveForums 3.7
Investment Club Tools Investor Advisory Service Historical data by Historical prices by Instant Stock Analysis by About ICLUBcentral Inc.
myiclubBadge.gif IASBadge.gif HemscottBadge.gif CSIBadge.gif TakeStockBadge.gif ICLUBcentralBadge.gif